Plot Twist: Season 4 of Glee is subtitled “Rutherford’s Revenge.”
Matt Rutherford transfers back to McKinley and becomes male lead of the glee club and quarterback of the football team. He is the father of Sue’s baby, dates Blaine, and gets elected Prom King AND Prom Queen simultaneously. His first dance with himself is also a solo he sings, Drake’s “The Motto.”
In the season finale he gets into NYADA three times.
And he never auditioned.